Schizoaffective Disorder Vs Schizophrenia: Differences

What is the Difference Between Schizophrenia and Schizoaffective Disorder?

Diagnosing mental health conditions like schizoaffective disorder vs schizophrenia can be complicated. The process leaves families confused and looking for answers. Whenever there are symptoms that intermingle, like symptoms of both psychosis and mood, a major diagnostic challenge arises.

In this case, the cost of an incorrect diagnosis is very high. Treatment type, recovery time, and stigma may impact the person’s living experience for years to come.

There is a clinical urgency to get it right. Early diagnosis and accurate diagnosis are essential to getting the patient stable and having positive outcomes.

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM-5-TR, as a tool, is the gold standard for diagnosis. Clinicians use it to assess complex presentations of symptoms. We are going to simplify these complexities and study symptom patterns, diagnosis evolution, and effective treatment variables.

Core Definitions & Diagnostic Criteria

As you traverse the diagnostic terrain, it is critical to understand the general definitions and distinguishing features of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder.

Schizophrenia

According to the DSM-5-TR, there are a variety of symptoms. To meet a schizophrenia diagnosis, the patient must be experiencing at least one of these core symptoms.

• Auditory input hallucinations (e.g., hearing voices)
• Visual input hallucinations (e.g., seeing people who are not there)
• Delusions ranging from persecutory to grandiose, or disorganized thinking

Importantly, mood is not a defining criterion. Mood episodes may occur at some point, but are not the defining feature. 

The symptoms must persist for at least the last six months and cause significant functional impairment throughout that period. The DSM-IV made note of subtypes, including paranoid, disorganized, and catatonic. These subtypes are now considered obsolete as this article follows the DSM-5-TR.

Schizoaffective Disorder

Schizoaffective is a different set of maladies. Dual pathology has psychotic symptoms plus major mood episodes (depressive or manic). Importantly, schizoaffective disorder includes psychotic symptoms persisting for two weeks or more without mood symptoms at any point.

Symptom Profiles: Beyond Overlap

Schizophrenia is often characterized by steady and progressive deterioration of social functioning. It also includes severe cognitive disorganization as a manifestation of psychosis. 

Symptoms of schizoaffective disorder include more dynamic social functioning and cognitive presentation. It acquires its value based on the severity of present or pending mood episodes. Impulsivity is a notable feature of manic periods.

Schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorders exhibit a greater degree of disruption in the form of psychosis.

Shared Psychotic Features

These include hallucinations (perceptions of things not present, typically auditory) and delusions (fixed, false beliefs, such as themes indicative of persecution or issues of grandeur).

Classes of Negative Symptoms

Anhedonia (inability to feel pleasure) and avolition (inability to initiate or persist in goal-directed behavior) tend to be more significant in their severity in schizophrenia, which includes deep emotional blunting.

Symptom Profiles: Beyond Overlap

People with schizoaffective disorder have distinctive mood components. They have clear, chronic major mood episodes.

This can be major depressive disorder or mania.

Depressive disorder symptoms include:

• Suicidal ideation
• Severe fatigue
• Feelings of worthlessness

Mania symptoms include:

• Risk-taking behavior
• Sleeplessness
• Racing thoughts

In schizophrenia, mood disturbances occur but do not generally seem to be primary. Symptoms of depression can occur related to the challenges and isolation of living with chronic psychosis.

Social function in schizophrenia typically shows a decline over time, leading to chronic withdrawal and impairment. In contrast, social function in schizoaffective disorder tends to vary, recovering during times of remission of mood symptoms. 

Cognitively, schizophrenia often includes disorganization of thought. While the cognitive features may be impulsive, as dictated by the person experiencing mood swings.

Treatment Strategies: Tailoring Approaches

Treatment for schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorders is highly individualized and primarily pharmacological. Antipsychotics are utilized to treat psychotic symptoms for both disorders. For example, hallucinations and delusions, using medications like risperidone.  

However, the treatment for schizoaffective disorder is much more complicated due to having a mood aspect sandwiched between the schizophrenia aspect. The bipolar type of schizoaffective disorder requires mood stabilizers, e.g., lithium, to rid acute manic episodes.

For the depressive type, SSRIs (Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors) are routinely used. However, with some caution because they could also exacerbate psychotic symptoms.

The solutions of adherence must be addressed since they are chronic illnesses. Long Acting Injectables (LAIs) are helpful for those who are unreliable with medication.

Families need psychoeducation, including what to expect, medication timetables, and compliance to support them for the long haul.

Prognosis & Functional Outcomes

There are significant differences in the long-term prognosis and day-to-day functioning of individuals with schizophrenia versus schizoaffective disorder. This is due to the differences in core symptoms and response to treatment.

Schizophrenia

In general, schizophrenia has a chronic course with about 70% experiencing moderately to severely impairing symptoms (“lifelong disability”). If treated with medication, relapse rates are much higher partly, because many patients do not consistently take medications and that is very important, especially with schizophrenia. 

Schizoaffective Disorder

Schizoaffective disorder can provide better functional recovery than schizophrenia since there is more opportunity for mood stabilization. However, it must be acknowledged that schizoaffective disorder comes with an increased risk of suicide, especially during depression. Monitoring and medications may help check this potential risk.

Global Statistics

Globally, about 1% of people have schizophrenia. Schizoaffective disorder is typically considered less commonly seen, estimated at around 0.3%.

This is likely an underestimate due to the complexity of the disorder, which can lead to underdiagnosis or misdiagnosis. This makes the true prevalence more difficult to understand.

Responding to Crises: Family & Clinical Response

Crises in the context of schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder require fluid and immediate attention at both the family history level and clinical level. Managing crises appropriately is crucial to safety and long-term outcomes. 

De-escalation

In the case of acute psychotic symptoms, it is ideal to de-escalate situations quickly and safely. Clarifying and validating the individual’s emotions (“That sounds scary,” “I can see you are upset”) is better than directly challenging their delusions or hallucinations.

These hallucinations are symptoms of the illness, and directly challenging someone about their reality tends to exacerbate agitation and mistrust. This can be more complicated when suicidality or violence is posed because definitive emergency protocols must be determined. There are many helpful resources available across the United States that can help.

This can initiate immediate support of active outreach by trained counselors to individuals and families in crisis and establish a connection of support. There are similar emergency response mental health services in other parts of the world, and it is always beneficial to be aware of an emergency number in your area.

Diagnostic Pitfalls

During a crisis, it is especially hard to tell the difference between disorders that present similarly. One diagnostic pitfall is substance use. Recreational substance abuse (e.g., cannabis and LSD) can mimic psychosis and precipitate an acute psychotic episode. Patients should be drug tested to rule it out.

Another common pitfall is distinguishing mood disorders with psychotic features from schizoaffective disorder. Mood disorder episodes, especially depressive or manic episodes, may have psychotic symptoms.

Schizoaffective disorder requires a period of at least two weeks of psychosis that is not during a prominent mood episode. The distinction is usually complicated during an acute crisis, but critical for accurate long-term diagnosis and treatment planning.

So, What Is the Difference Between Schizophrenia and Schizoaffective Disorder?

The key difference between these disorders is the presence of mood symptoms. Schizoaffective disorder includes the feature of psychosis, along with present mood episodes.

The mood disturbance is a more dominant and persistent feature of schizoaffective disorder. Schizophrenia is mainly psychotic; mood symptoms will be more secondary or even incidental to the diagnosis of schizophrenia.

The most important step for anyone with these complicated symptoms. Whether presenting as a mood disorder or a psychotic disorder, it is necessary to seek a specialist for an assessment.

An evaluation can only do so much. Assessment covers a long period of time and allows clinicians to observe the course of symptoms. There will be some reality-testing involved, and early intervention would have the most impact on functional outcomes. That way, the onset of better long-term stability.

In the end, the important message is hope; both of these disorders can be treated with tailored application of therapy and antipsychotic medication. While they will be challenging, individuals can learn to achieve strong stability and improve their life situation. The best way to figure out the difference between schizoaffective vs schizophrenia is by seeking help from a mental health professional.

Are you, your family member, or a friend having mental health problems? Reach out to We Level Up for diagnosis and treatment.

Summary

Call today to speak with our team and learn more about our programs. We Level Up Washington: (509) 348-4077. Your next step starts here.